![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
raxFirst sentence: "We live in a world populated by structures --- a complex mixture of geological, biological, social, and linguistic constructions that are nothing but accumulations of materials shaped and hardened by history." I like this already.
Buildings as a parallel to bone, allowing for movement that wasn't possible for flesh previously. <3 Author points out that cities are not organisms in "A state of internal equilibrium" and it's important to consider them as "dynamical systems operating far from equilibrium."
Birth of Europe made possible by the ability to much more efficiently exploit soil. (I bet there's a parallel here to technological shifts allowing us to much more efficiently exploit oil; earlier de Landa says that we developed cities in the first place because we more efficiently exploited solar power through plant cultivation.) Oh right he mentions that parallel in, like, the next paragraph. Go me.
"Bureaucracies have always arisen to effect a planned extraction of energy surpluses." Bureaucracies as homogenous hierarchies, markets (like a farmer's market not like an Almacs [0]) as heterogeneous. Meshworks versus hierarchies! de Landa: "meshworks and hierarchies not only coexist and intermingle, they constantly give rise to one another. For example, as markets grow in size, they tend to form commercial hierarchies."
On page 12, a bunch of things about how "explosive" change can't happen when hierarchy overwhelms meshwork and that's why Europe was dominant for a millenium. ...really? de Landa holds the authors saying that at a distance, it will be interesting to see wehre he goes with it. Certainly mostly-hierarchical systems and mostly-meshy systems are going to behave somewhat differently...
Money as: energy but in the opposite direction, political rather than economic, a catalyst.
"not only resources change hands in the market but also property rights" has been said twice so I guess I should write it down. I mean, this seems kind of obvious to me?
Difference between looking at totalities and large-scale entities --- looking at cities lets us examine patterns but maintain specificity. Groups of cities can themselves form hierarchical patterns. Cities can also form meshworks. Long-distance trading centers are an example of that. That's a Network system versus a "Central Pyramid" which may or may not be his term, I dunno. Network core shift: "Venice, Antwerp, Genoa, Amsterdam, London, New York." Different cultural patterns. Pyramids tend to homogenize, networks tend not to.
"urban patterns do not result from some global optimizer (such as superrational human decision makers minimizing transportation costs) but from a dynamics of cooperation and conflict among cities, involving growth and decay of centers." Yup, people aren't rational actors. There's a good reformulation of this idea in here though: "...the inherent costs of information gathering. Imperfect knowledge, incomplete assessment of feedback, limited memory and recall, as well as poor problem-solving skills result in a form of rationality that attains not optimal decisions but more or less satisfactory compromises between conflicting constraints."
"Many preindustrial cities can be seen as large reservoirs of skills and routines." Sort of like employers in a sense. ...oh and it leads to the guild system!
Capitalism wasn't all supply and demand in the 13th century, there was a lot of noncompetitive behavior for metagaming reasons. Basically this paper is telling me things about how people handle negotiation that I learned in "Competitive Decision Making And Negotiation" which was still the best class.
"As philosophers of science know well, when a theory begins redefining its terms in an ad hoc way to fit the latest round of negative evidence, it shows by this very act that it has reached the limits of its usefulness."
Credit and compound interest as a form of explosive growth that creates power.
Metropolis (Venice) as membrane, exploiting distant resources, capital (Paris) exploits local resources
Page 29 has really interesting stuff on European domination --- China/Islam were poised to do better as of 1500, what about Europe made it come out ahead? Many of the inventions (gunpowder, paper money) came from China, and the credit system came from Islam (a little weird using Islam as a term for a cultural region but I'm paraphrasing here and using the words the essay uses). So being a meshwork prevented Europe from being "too dependent on the individual skills of their elites?" Huh. "An idiot sultan could paralyze the Ottoman Empire in a way that a pope or Holy Roman Emperor could never do for all of Europe." I guess I can buy that. London and Amsterdam were maritime cities, outward focus, therefore in a better position to colonize. Huh. This is a really interesting lens though I'd be skeptical of using it as the only one.
Harnessing wind power in the form of trade winds as a step between plant/solar and oil! FASCINATING.
These are all non-linear models. In conclusion, this paper is badass, although perhaps somewhat limited in trying to fit everything into its approach.
[0] Non Rhode Islanders can follow http://rimag.biz/ALMACS.html
Buildings as a parallel to bone, allowing for movement that wasn't possible for flesh previously. <3 Author points out that cities are not organisms in "A state of internal equilibrium" and it's important to consider them as "dynamical systems operating far from equilibrium."
Birth of Europe made possible by the ability to much more efficiently exploit soil. (I bet there's a parallel here to technological shifts allowing us to much more efficiently exploit oil; earlier de Landa says that we developed cities in the first place because we more efficiently exploited solar power through plant cultivation.) Oh right he mentions that parallel in, like, the next paragraph. Go me.
"Bureaucracies have always arisen to effect a planned extraction of energy surpluses." Bureaucracies as homogenous hierarchies, markets (like a farmer's market not like an Almacs [0]) as heterogeneous. Meshworks versus hierarchies! de Landa: "meshworks and hierarchies not only coexist and intermingle, they constantly give rise to one another. For example, as markets grow in size, they tend to form commercial hierarchies."
On page 12, a bunch of things about how "explosive" change can't happen when hierarchy overwhelms meshwork and that's why Europe was dominant for a millenium. ...really? de Landa holds the authors saying that at a distance, it will be interesting to see wehre he goes with it. Certainly mostly-hierarchical systems and mostly-meshy systems are going to behave somewhat differently...
Money as: energy but in the opposite direction, political rather than economic, a catalyst.
"not only resources change hands in the market but also property rights" has been said twice so I guess I should write it down. I mean, this seems kind of obvious to me?
Difference between looking at totalities and large-scale entities --- looking at cities lets us examine patterns but maintain specificity. Groups of cities can themselves form hierarchical patterns. Cities can also form meshworks. Long-distance trading centers are an example of that. That's a Network system versus a "Central Pyramid" which may or may not be his term, I dunno. Network core shift: "Venice, Antwerp, Genoa, Amsterdam, London, New York." Different cultural patterns. Pyramids tend to homogenize, networks tend not to.
"urban patterns do not result from some global optimizer (such as superrational human decision makers minimizing transportation costs) but from a dynamics of cooperation and conflict among cities, involving growth and decay of centers." Yup, people aren't rational actors. There's a good reformulation of this idea in here though: "...the inherent costs of information gathering. Imperfect knowledge, incomplete assessment of feedback, limited memory and recall, as well as poor problem-solving skills result in a form of rationality that attains not optimal decisions but more or less satisfactory compromises between conflicting constraints."
"Many preindustrial cities can be seen as large reservoirs of skills and routines." Sort of like employers in a sense. ...oh and it leads to the guild system!
Capitalism wasn't all supply and demand in the 13th century, there was a lot of noncompetitive behavior for metagaming reasons. Basically this paper is telling me things about how people handle negotiation that I learned in "Competitive Decision Making And Negotiation" which was still the best class.
"As philosophers of science know well, when a theory begins redefining its terms in an ad hoc way to fit the latest round of negative evidence, it shows by this very act that it has reached the limits of its usefulness."
Credit and compound interest as a form of explosive growth that creates power.
Metropolis (Venice) as membrane, exploiting distant resources, capital (Paris) exploits local resources
Page 29 has really interesting stuff on European domination --- China/Islam were poised to do better as of 1500, what about Europe made it come out ahead? Many of the inventions (gunpowder, paper money) came from China, and the credit system came from Islam (a little weird using Islam as a term for a cultural region but I'm paraphrasing here and using the words the essay uses). So being a meshwork prevented Europe from being "too dependent on the individual skills of their elites?" Huh. "An idiot sultan could paralyze the Ottoman Empire in a way that a pope or Holy Roman Emperor could never do for all of Europe." I guess I can buy that. London and Amsterdam were maritime cities, outward focus, therefore in a better position to colonize. Huh. This is a really interesting lens though I'd be skeptical of using it as the only one.
Harnessing wind power in the form of trade winds as a step between plant/solar and oil! FASCINATING.
These are all non-linear models. In conclusion, this paper is badass, although perhaps somewhat limited in trying to fit everything into its approach.
[0] Non Rhode Islanders can follow http://rimag.biz/ALMACS.html
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2010-09-15 01:54 pm (UTC)Although surely plant->wind->oil is missing a step and some significant overlaps...
(no subject)
Date: 2010-09-14 08:58 pm (UTC)I've found all your posts from this class interesting, but I have to admit that I'm particularly piqued by this one. The fault-tolerance of the European political system is another great line; am I correct in thinking China had a political structure more like the Ottoman Empire than like Europe?
(no subject)
Date: 2010-09-15 02:32 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2010-09-15 08:24 am (UTC)скачать скайп 6.1
Date: 2011-06-17 09:50 am (UTC)скачать фильмы новинки торрент [url=http://vialoigrineab.tk/skachat-programmu-dlya-umnozheniya-golosov-404.html]скачать программу для умножения голосов[/url] хранители скачать книгу bonusscanner 3.3 5 a скачать скачать word 2003 с ключом трансформеры 3 скачать [url=http://rialeatoro.tk/skachat-temy-thm-935.html]скачать темы thm[/url] скачать музыку гимн скачать бладрейн игру торрент курсы английского языка скачать торрент
скачать скайп 5.1 русская версия скачать видео зайчик [url=http://guifirowor.tk/skachat-dp-video-898.html]скачать дп видео[/url] скачать анимэ порно титаник фильм скачать торрент скачать фильм сын как отец [url=http://vialoigrineab.tk/skachat-temy-dlya-saita-707.html]скачать темы для сайта[/url] скачать альбом денис майданов
как скачать 100500 [url=http://vialoigrineab.tk/skachat-resident-4-torrent-235.html]скачать resident 4 торрент[/url] на море фильм скачать торрент скачать microsoft office 2010 x64 хит лета 2011 скачать как вернуть любимого скачать [url=http://rebargede.tk/skachat-programmu-yazyk-si-990.html]скачать программу язык си[/url] скачать курс китайского языка скачать темы для 8800 музыка белых скачать
учебник русский язык класс скачать скачать учебник биболетовой 4 класс [url=http://lamalrasoc.tk/skachat-rybka-4-532.html]скачать rybka 4[/url] брат 2 саундтреки скачать скачать камеди на телефон скачать игры java 5 [url=http://brisroomsdonta.tk/skachat-doktor-veb-5-413.html]скачать доктор веб 5[/url] языки программирования скачать
скачать драйвер звуковой платы [url=http://bulleftquabma.tk/kak-skachat-igru-na-disk-386.html]как скачать игру на диск[/url] скачать книгу край dan balan mp3 скачать скачать песню елена matlab 7 скачать [url=http://geabpusundlink.tk/igry-360-skachat-70.html]игры 360 скачать[/url] скачать игру алхимик на телефон скачать песню скучаю скачать джава книги
скачать sims 2010 самсунг gt s5560 скачать темы [url=http://vialoigrineab.tk/skachat-progu-dlya-otpravki-sms-373.html]скачать прогу для отправки смс[/url] скачать язык программирования pascal 7600 gt драйвер скачать скачать морские игры торрент [url=http://ladefderep.tk/skachat-sochinenie-na-temu-lyubov-768.html]скачать сочинение на тему любовь[/url] скачать альбом группы русские
скачать песни 2010 [url=http://surdiosaygym.tk/skachat-film-vprityk-torrent-769.html]скачать фильм впритык торрент[/url] каникулы каникулы скачать музыку фаервол скачать на русском языке скачать анимационные заставки на компьютер скачать фильм к морю [url=http://bulleftquabma.tk/skachat-rep-75.html]скачать реп[/url] заградотряд фильм скачать торрент скачать песню далеко далеко скачать темы на телефон samsung